Evaluating Web Sites
Title of web page: __________________________________________________
Web page address (URL): ____________________________________________
Date accessed: _________________
Authority
- Who is (are) the author(s) or sponsoring organization(s)? ______________________________________________________
- Is (are) the author(s) clearly identified? _________
- Are the authors and/or maintainers of the site authorities in their field?_________
- Can you contact the author(s)?___________
- If so, how?____________________
- Does the URL or web address indicate the publisher or sponsor of the web site?________________
- Is there any other information about the author or publisher?___________
- What is the purpose of the web page? _____________________________________________________________________
Accuracy
- Is the information verifiable in another source?__________________
- Does the web page use correct spelling and grammar?______________
- Are the author's sources given credit with full citation information?_________
Objectivity
- Is there any bias towards the subject matter?_____________
- If so, what is the bias? _________________________________________
- Does the author/publisher have a particular viewpoint, which influences the content or presentation of the information?_______________
- Does the information seem to be in good taste and free from stereotyping?_________
- Are advertisements present on the site?________________
- Do the viewpoints of the advertiser(s) influence the content of the information?____________
Currency
- Is the date of the last revision or update posted?__________
- If so, what is the date?______________
- Is it recent enough for the subject matter of the site?__________
Coverage
- What is the topic?_____________________________________________
- Is it covered in depth?__________
- Does the information on this web page fulfill its intended purpose?_________
- Is a site map or table of contents provided?___________________
- Is it easy to get to?____________________
Other Issues
- Is the site easy to use?___________
- Is the information clearly labeled and organized?__________
- Are there any software requirements, other than a browser, to view the page?__________
- Are all the hyperlinks live and working?____________
- If you found a lower tiered page on the site, can it stand alone?___________
- Is there a link from that lower page to the main page?________
|